Best Bagged Compost for Vegetable Gardens of 2021: Complete Reviews With Comparisons

Best Bagged Compost for Vegetable Gardens of 2021: Complete Reviews With Comparisons

If you are looking to grow your own vegetables or any other plants, you will need to find healthy soil to provide your plants with the proper nourishment they need.

Thankfully, nowadays, you do not need to find good farmland, as all you need is the best bagged compost for vegetable gardens.

They allow you to grow plants outdoors and indoors even with limited space.

There are plenty of brands in the market, and each brand offers several types of compost.

Thus, we’ve scoured the market and found five compost products that you can consider purchasing and using.

We’ve looked into each bag’s features, pros, and cons to help you decide which one will work best for your needs.

Best Bagged Compost for Vegetable Gardens: A Review

1. Charlie’s Compost

Located in Louisville, Kentucky, Charlie’s Compost is Certified Organic by the state.

It’s been part of the agricultural chemical manufacturing industry for years now.

By providing reliable products that buyers grew to love, the company has gradually established itself as an authority in the field.

This bagged compost by the company checks all the important marks of an ideal vegetable compost.

It does not contain any antibiotics, which is becoming fairly common nowadays when companies use Ivermectin or GMOs to enhance results.

In just a matter of a few weeks after using it, you’ll start to notice a significant difference in your beloved plants.

If you want something with the same effect as synthetic fertilizers, this compost is worth checking out.


The Charlie’s Compost contains straw, hay, clay, cornstalks, chicken manure, forest products, and beneficial microbial inoculants.

According to the manufacturer, the ingredients in each bag are composted in windrows for about eight to 12 weeks.

Each Charlie’s Compost bag contains about 10 pounds or two cubic feet of compost.

From testing, this compost does an excellent job for the most part, which is crucial considering it is expensive.

However, it is important to note that getting some bags that are not as high quality as the others is possible.

Some bags are not filled to the ten-pound limit, suggesting a quality control issue with Charlie’s Compost.

Despite not contributing to its performance, another great thing about Charlie’s Compost is its superb packaging.

You’d want to pay attention to this aspect because you want to receive a healthy compost batch.


  • Ideal ingredients
  • Works well for most plants
  • Comes in properly sealed packaging
  • Odorless


  • Expensive
  • Quality issues

2. Michigan Peat 5240 Garden Magic Compost and Manure

This compost is manufactured by a company committed to providing only the best-formulated products to professionals and hobbyists alike.

As a long-time supplier, Michigan Peat emphasizes the responsible use of raw materials to reach the perfect balance between nature and science.

At the core of their culture is the utmost respect for the environment, a core value they’ve been practicing for decades.

Like the company itself, which is built from the ground up, this compost is a product of intensive improvement over the years.

The Michigan Peat 5240 is a high-end compost meant for making sure your garden comes out rich and healthy.

Packed with nutrients and free of debris, this is as pure as you will get.


The Michigan Peat 5240 Garden Magic Compost and Manure is odor-free and contains natural organic ingredients, such as composted animal manure and reed sedge peat.

It is beautifully dark, rich with nutrients, and does not contain rocks, sticks, bugs, and more.

If you do find foreign objects from time to time, it’s nothing alarming because they actually help with the moisture level of the compost.

The Michigan Peat 5240 has an almost silky texture to it with intense black color.

Also, if your natural soil isn’t very good, you can mix this compost with store-bought soil and expect good results.


  • Odor-free
  • High quality 
  • Organic ingredients


  • Out of stock almost all the time
  • Price fluctuates

3. Malibu Compost Bu’s Best Biodynamic Compost Tomato Tea

Bu’s Best Biodynamic Compost Tomato Tea is manufactured by a company that puts animal rights at the forefront of its operations.

Like many successful business ventures, Malibu Compost came into existence by addressing a specific problem.

That is to produce good organic compost that will result in clean and healthy food.

It is the product of collaboration among experts in different fields.

As the first biodynamic company in the USA, it developed its most popular product, the compost tomato tea.

When you are looking to grow tomatoes, this is the tea for you.

That said, Bu’s Best Biodynamic Compost Tomato Tea is useful for many plants, making this a good choice for most vegetable gardens.


This compost has been crafted with innovation in mind, using proprietary biodynamic preparations purposely designed for better tomato care.

You can use it as a soil drench, foliar feed, and transplant root booster.

Keep in mind that it has microbes, so proper care involves storing it in a cool, dry place.

You must also keep it away from sunlight, as even the tiniest moisture can activate the microbes.

The Malibu Compost Bu’s Best Biodynamic Compost Tomato Tea will also eventually give off a foul smell if left unattended.

It is also very fast-acting, so you’ll normally see results within a few days.

Although it does work well on its own, you need to include additives, such as molasses and other organic fertilizers, when you brew it.

Typically, you can make four to five brews with one bag, and you can use a single bag to grow plants in multiple gardens, offering great value for its price.

It is essential, though, to make sure you brew the tomato tea using water with a temperature that’s the same as the surrounding.


  • Good value for money
  • Very effective
  • Odorless


  • Needs additives to maximize effects
  • Price fluctuates

4. Soil Blend Super Compost

The Super Compost by Soil Blend is a non-GMO organic concentrated product approved and recommended by the American Vegetarian Association.

It is perfect for those living the vegetarian lifestyle, as you do not have to worry about harmful chemicals or harming animals in the process.

Aside from fighting for animal rights, the company is also making considerable efforts in sustainability projects, one of which is the product we’re about to review.

This compost concentrate will allow you to supplement your lifestyle by making it easier to grow your own all-natural and organic food right in the comfort of home.

Of course, with its formula, professionals can use it on a larger scale.


The Soil Blend Super Compost includes several great ingredients that your plants will love, so it can boost yields and create bigger and more delicious fruits and vegetables.

It contains organic ingredients like alfalfa, beef cow manure, earthworm castings, calcium plus, magnesium, sulfur, iron, and micronutrients.

It also has a plant growth hormone called triacontanol.

To use the Soil Blend Super Compost, you need to mix it with soil using a 1:4 ratio: one part compost and four parts soil.

With an eight-pound bag, you should be able to produce around 40 pounds.

That said, even with this ratio and the organic and non-GMO ingredients, it is on the expensive side.

If you have the time and means, it is possible to create over ten times the amount of product at the same price.

But if cost is not a problem for you, the Soil Blend Super Compost is an excellent option.


  • AVA approved
  • Non-GMO ingredients
  • Effective
  • Odorless


  • On the pricey side
  • Eight-pound quantity
  • Needs to be mixed with other soil

5. O.N.E “Organic New Earth” Organic Soil Additive

 best bagged compost for vegetable gardens

The Organic New Earth is an all-natural soil additive that you can use on outdoor and indoor plants.

It is made in the USA and is USDA certified for agricultural purposes.

The manufacturing company, GEC Organics, is dedicated to developing the best products and promoting sustainability.

Founded in 2011, this company has been encouraging all key players in the agriculture industry to steer away from using synthetic fertilizers.

With their all-natural soil amendment initiative, they seek to promote a healthier way to grow crops.

They also provide support and assistance to farmers to improve every step of the process, from preparing the soil to harvesting.

To get more tangible results, they developed the Organic New Earth Soil Additive.

You can use this completely odorless additive for breathing new life into old soil or enhancing new soil to ensure your plants have the nutrients they need to grow healthy.


You can use the Organic New Earth soil additive to help your fruits, vegetables, and other plants grow larger, faster, and healthier.

You can liberally apply the Organic New Earth without worrying about harming your plants or burning their roots, which other products could easily do if you are not careful.

It can also help revive almost dead plants and give them a new lease on life.

The O.N.E “Organic New Earth” Organic Soil Additive also offers great value for money since you can mix it with other soil using a 3:1 ratio.

This way, you can create 15 pounds from a five-pound bag.

You can also use this as an additive to compost tea, such as the previous compost we reviewed.


  • Made in the USA
  • Odorless
  • Works exceptionally well
  • Great value for money
  • Safe to use liberally
  • Nutrient-rich


  • May become the only additive you’d want to use

Final Recommendations

Gardening can be a delicate endeavor, and sometimes it can feel like no matter what you do, you just cannot keep your plants alive and flourishing.

Fortunately, the products we reviewed can help tip things in your favor!

Our favorite, though, is the high-quality, odorless Garden Magic Compost and Manure. With it, it has never been easier to create a blooming garden regardless of what you want to grow.

Growing lush and delicious vegetables is as simple as mixing the compost into your soil then watching the results happen before your very eyes.

Another great alternative to consider is the Bu’s Best Biodynamic Compost Tomato Tea, which you can brew and mix into your current soil to enhance and revitalize it.

It is a wonderful way to give your tomato and vegetable garden the nutrients they need to flourish.

Just remember that there isn’t exactly a best bagged compost for vegetable gardens because many variables go into raising a healthy garden, from soil to weather.

Sometimes, a garden may not work out because of your climate.

Still, these two products will definitely go a long way in providing the results you are looking for!